Skip to Content
On Your Side, at Your Side—Every Step of the Way
Get in Touch: (888) 639-4817
Top
Frequently Asked Questions

After a Car Accident, Do I Have to Accept the Settlement that The Insurance Company Offers? What Can I Do if It’s Too Low? 

First and foremost, you should keep in mind that the at-fault driver’s insurance company does not have your best interest in mind after an accident. No matter how severe your injury is, or how much you’re suffering, it is likely that they are more worried about paying you out as quickly as possible than giving you the amount you need to compensate the affects of your injury.

When the at-fault insurance company offers you an initial settlement amount, it will be in your best interest to consult an experienced personal injury attorney before you accept or decline the offer. An attorney can help you determine whether the offer is too low based on the nature of your injury and recovery. Insurance adjusters are trained to purely process your claim in accordance with the insurance contract and financial interest of the company they work for. An attorney with experience that knows what is appropriate under the terms of the contract with the insurance company and the law for liability and damages claims available to you under the law and particular facts of your case is what is needed.

If the offer is too low, it should be rejected and the reasoning behind the rejection should be explained. Evidence to explain the rejection of an offer that’s too low may be a doctor’s note describing your injuries, the diagnosis or treatment, and the unpaid time you had to take off work to heal. Evidence can also come in the form of photos of bruising or scarring that prove how painful or limiting the injury is. Statements or letters from people you had to pay to do household work or run errands while you recover from your injury can also serve as proof that you require more compensation than the original offer.

If you’re wondering why the offer was so low in the first place, it may be because the at-fault insurance company doesn’t have all the documentation of your losses on file. Having an attorney on your side to help evaluate the need for more receipts for past expenses whether they are property damage, medical bills, or lost wages can make the process go more smoothly. But, it’s important that you have all the information necessary to communicate these losses to the insurance company — keeping track of pay stubs, receipts, and invoices is essential.

If negotiations for a fair settlement with the at-fault insurance company can’t be reached, that is where a lawsuit comes in to play. In a typical third party case, a lawsuit is filed against the party that hit you and their insurance company has a contract to defend them against your lawsuit. A lawsuit may be filed against the insurance company if it’s a first party claim like when an uninsured or underinsured motorist hits you or if your insurance company’s conduct is egregiously bad. Nobody should settle for pennies and dimes after suffering the consequences of an injury caused by someone else’s negligence.

If you have further questions or concerns about dealing with the at-fault driver’s insurance company, and the settlement process, don’t hesitate to contact the personal injury attorneys at Kelley and Canterbury, LLC. We have helped clients in Anchorage, AK get the compensation they deserve for their injuries and damages.

Standing Strong for Alaska’s Injured

Why Clients Choose Us
  • Boutique Firm, Big Results

    We offer the personalized attention of a boutique firm with the ability to secure the compensation you deserve for injuries of all types.

  • Local Knowledge, National Recognition

    Rooted in Anchorage, we’ve built a legacy of excellence, trusted locally and by national firms for co-counsel and representation.

  • Peace of Mind After Personal Injury

    We handle the legal work so you can focus on healing. From insurance claims to court representation, we’re with you every step of the way.

  • Anchorage’s Trusted Advocates Since 1975
    For nearly 50 years, we’ve helped Alaskans recover after devastating accidents, holding negligent parties accountable for their actions.

Get in Touch Today

Fill Out the Form Below to Get Started

A member of our team will be in touch shortly to confirm your contact details or address questions you may have.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy
    *This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship

Our Clients Come First

Testimonials That Speak Volumes

At Kelley & Canterbury, your satisfaction is our priority! See for yourself what our clients have to say about working with us.

    "I would recommend him to anyone who is looking for an attorney who will fight for them!"

    Chris Canterbury was here for me and my family when we needed him the most. He is so good at what he does and I would recommend him to anyone who is looking for an attorney who will fight for them! His office staff is so friendly and always available to answer any questions along the way.

    K.P.
    "An excellent team bar none!"

    Michaela Canterbury exceeded all my expectations with her knowledge and professional work ethics. Over 10 firms had turned my case down and I was ready to give up. Mrs. Canterbury was able to help me process memories and emotions that might have been overlooked and always had a lighthearted approach with good humor that lifted my spirit. An excellent team bar none!

    C.O.
    "Respectful, kindhearted, and always put me as the client first!"

    Highly recommend! Chris and the entire Kelley and Canterbury team where awesome! Can’t thank them enough! They were respectful, kindhearted, and always put me as the client first! They walked me through every step of my case and made sure I was aware of everything going on with the case. Chris was extremely knowledgeable and knew how to get me taken care of. Thank you Kelley and Canterbury!

    B.T.
    "I will definitely be using them for all my future legal needs."
    They really make you feel like you’re at home and they make sure they will get the most they can for you and your family no matter what.
    A.E.
    "Kelley and Canterbury absolutely went above and beyond for me."
    Being in their office always felt like being with family which made asking my uneducated questions so much easier for me.
    J.A.
    "I am forever grateful for their hard work."
    Michaela and Chris are truly exceptional attorneys and people in general. They are particular about taking care with each clients needs and have shown compassion throughout my experience.
    V.J.
    "Michaela advocated for me as if I were a member of her family."
    Michaela made sure I understood what to expect for the long process ahead of us but even more important, she was empathetic to what I was going through post-accident.
    A.K.
    "They made me feel like family."
    Kelley and Canterbury are more than amazing. They made me feel like family, they cared about the pain my family and I experienced after our accident, emotionally and physically. The staff in the office are incredibly hard working, positive and make you feel part of the team. We will choose Kelley and Canterbury every time!
    H.O.